Me: "What are you eating?"
Son: "My boogers. Can I do that, Mom?"
Me: "Sure, you can do that."
Here's the thing. If I say, "No, you can't." That's a lie. Obviously, he has the ability to eat that which he extracts from his nose. If I say, "Yes, you can, but don't because I don't want you to," I'm telling him that he should do what I want him to do because I say so. That's not what I want for my children (the explanation requires another post). So, I just said, "Sure ... ."
Of course I don't want him to eat his boogers in public, but I think that's one of those social learning moments ... it's up to him to decide whether or not he wants to gross out his friends when he gets to the age that his friends actually think its gross (he's not there yet -- trust me).
Anyway, some things are just better left up to social learning opportunities in my opinion. One day he'll decide that they are gross enough not to eat, or he'll decide that he doesn't care what others think -- both seem like fine decisions to me.
What would you have said? I mean, how do we teach children manners and yet not turn them into little socially agreeable robots? Oh, the rambles of a stay-at-home mother.
I'll spare you the accompanying picture ;)
Monday, October 6, 2008
Teaching Manners
Posted by Emily at 1:05 PM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
emily, i have absolutely no insight into your question, but feel compelled to thank you for the evening giggle! hehe. kids are awesome!
They are so cute, aren't they?
Any signs of #3's impending arrival? I'm still hoping for an Oct. 15 birthday ... that's mine :) Since I'm not the one carrying her, I have different priorities ;)
nope, no sign of impending arrival. argh! so tortuous! glad my mom is here now though. they don't do weekly appointments here, and she didn't even do an exam at my last appointment (a week and a half ago?) to see if i was dilated or anything, so i have no idea if there's any progress! not that it should matter. with both of the other kiddos i walked around for weeks at 3-4cm. next appointment is on my due date.
LOVE this!! Well said.
Thanks, Lee :)
Ooh, the contentious and complex issue of manners! How should we teach them and what particular manners should we teach? - i.e. which particular manners are important enough to us adults/parents that we feel that we would like to impart them to our progeny? And furthermore, just because we believe one shouldn't (for example) eat with one's elbows on the table, should we "teach" such things to our kids or just let them acquire their own... um... set of social graces? (as it were)
I am so looking forward to all this stuff! ;-)))
Post a Comment